Types of Yeast: A Baker’s Guide to Bread-Raising Power

a table topped with lots of pink flowers and sourdough starter

Let’s Talk Yeast: Your Bread’s Best Buddy!

Ah, yeast—the magical ingredient that turns dough into fluffy, delicious bread. If you’ve ever been baffled by the yeast aisle at the store, fret not! Here’s a friendly guide to help you navigate the world of yeast options:

Active Dry Yeast: Oldie but Goodie

This classic yeast has stood the test of time. You’ll need to wake it up by proving it in warm water with a pinch of sugar. Wait a few minutes until it gets all bubbly—like a cozy little science experiment in your kitchen! If it stays flat, it’s time to bid adieu and get a fresh batch. This one usually takes longer to rise, but many report this one lasts longer than the others in how active it remains.

a white table topped with different types of food

Instant Yeast: Quick and Versatile

Instant yeast comes in two types—one for regular bread and another for sweet treats like brioche. But guess what? You can totally use the regular kind for both! It’s ready to rock as soon as you mix it into your dough. Just note, it might take a tad longer to rise if your liquids are chilly, but instant yeast rises faster than active dry yeast. This is the one I use.

Baker’s Yeast: Fresh, but With Caution

Also known as fresh yeast, this one’s a bit of a diva. It’s mixed with refined flour or cornstarch, which might not align with your fresh milling dreams. So, it’s often better to opt for other types unless you have a specific craving for this one.

Sourdough Starter: The Wild Child

Not your average yeast! Sourdough starter is like a pet you feed and nurture. Mix flour and water, let it ferment, and watch it bubble and grow. It takes patience (around two weeks to get it going from scratch!), but you can always snag a bit from a friend to jump-start your sourdough journey, or buy starter and feed that. Sourdough breads take the longest to rise, but the benefits are many and often worth it for the complex flavor.

Homemade Yeast: DIY Adventure

Some brave souls craft their own yeast from potatoes, grapes, and other kitchen magic. It’s a wild ride, but we’ll save that tale for another day—maybe when we’ve got more time and potatoes on hand!

So there you have it, yeast in all its glorious forms! Whether you’re a bread-baking novice or a seasoned pro, choosing the right yeast can make all the difference. Experiment, have fun, and remember, the best breads often start with the perfect yeast friend.

If you haven’t yet, it would mean the world if you could subscribe to my mailing list (I’ll send you some free printable recipes and other goodies) and follow me on social media. Thank you!

May your kitchen be filled with the delightful aroma of freshly baked bread!

Fresh Milled Bomb-Diggity Stuffing
A family favorite, sure to wow everyone on your Thanksgiving table. It'll …
Spanakopita with Fresh-Milled Phyllo Dough
Spinach pie is one of those dishes that feels like a hug …
How to Make Fresh Milled Phyllo Dough at Home
This recipe for fresh-milled phyllo dough uses hard and durum wheat to …
Sourdough Ciabatta and Italian Bread
Make fresh Ciabatta rolls or Italian bread with my favorite bread recipe …

I only share products or ingredients on my site that I use and love personally. This will NEVER change. If someone asks me to review a product they send, it will be at their own risk because I don't filter my opinions for anyone. When you click a link to buy on my blog, it helps support me while costing you nothing.